Five Common Misconceptions About Hiring a Roofing Contractor in Simi Valley

Hiring a roofing contractor in Simi Valley shouldn’t feel like a gamble. But with so many options (and just as many horror stories), it’s no wonder homeowners feel overwhelmed. One quote seems too cheap. Another one has a “limited-time offer.” And let’s not even get started on the cousin-of-a-friend types with no website, no license, and no paper trail.

At Infinity Roofers, we’ve heard every roofing myth in the book—and we’re here to bust them wide open. If you’re planning a roof repair or replacement, knowing what’s true (and what’s not) will help you hire with confidence, not confusion.

Let’s break down the top roofing contractor myths homeowners in Simi Valley fall for—so you don’t.

Myth #1: “The Cheapest Quote Is Always the Best Deal”

We get it. Roofs are expensive, and if you’re staring down a quote that looks way lower than the rest, it’s tempting to sign and celebrate.

But here’s the deal: cheap doesn’t always mean value. Sometimes, that “great deal” comes at the cost of:

• Substandard materials
• No warranty
• No permits
• Or worse—no insurance

A genuinely affordable roofing contractor in Simi Valley still uses quality materials, follows code, and protects you with real coverage. If the quote is significantly lower than the others, that’s a red flag. You’re likely paying for it later in repairs, leaks, or even legal issues.

Pro Tip: Spend time comparing roofing bids side-by-side. A detailed breakdown shows where the cost differences really come from.

Myth #2: “All Roofing Contractors Are Basically the Same”

This one’s a doozy. Many homeowners think all roofers are interchangeable—just pick someone with a truck and a ladder, right?

Wrong.

A licensed roofing contractor in Simi Valley has gone through extensive testing, certification, and ongoing education to meet California’s legal requirements. A guy with a hammer and a smile? Not quite the same.

Here’s what sets the best roofing companies in Simi Valley apart:

• State license in good standing
• Proof of both liability and workers’ comp insurance
• Clear contracts and warranties
• Experienced, trained crews—not subcontracted day labor

Don’t assume all roofers bring the same level of experience or professionalism. Do your research, ask for credentials, and do a quick contractor license lookup. It’s fast, easy, and could save your roof.

Myth #3: “Licensing and Insurance Don’t Really Matter If They’ve Done Good Work Before”

This is a dangerous line of thinking. Maybe you’ve got a neighbor who swears by “Joe the Roofer,” and Joe did great work on their garage ten years ago. But here’s the thing: if Joe isn’t licensed or insured, you’re taking a considerable risk—no matter how nice his work looks.

Licensed roofers in Simi Valley aren’t just following the law—they’re protecting your home. If something goes wrong, they have the insurance and accountability to fix it. Unlicensed contractors? Not so much.

Hiring an insured roofing contractor also protects you if:

• Someone is injured on your property
• Materials get stolen or damaged
• The roof leaks six months later, and the installer ghosted you

If you’re thinking, “It probably won’t happen to me,” just know that roofing scams usually start with someone skipping the paperwork.

Myth #4: “Warranties Are Just Marketing Fluff”

Nope. Real warranties are worth their weight in shingles—especially when your roof faces years of heat, wind, and potential wildfire debris.

There are two types to look for:

• Manufacturer warranties (covering defects in the shingles or tiles)
• Workmanship warranties (covering installation mistakes or errors)

The trusted roofing professionals in Simi Valley will not only explain the differences—they’ll register the materials with the manufacturer and give you written proof.

Don’t fall for vague “we’ll take care of you” promises. Ask about length, transferability, and what voids the warranty. A roofing contractor who stands by their work has no problem putting it in writing.

Myth #5: “Hiring a Roofer Is Just About the Roof—Everything Else Will Work Itself Out”

Actually, hiring a roofer is about way more than shingles and nails.

The best roofers act as project managers, compliance advisors, and communication champions. From day one, they’ll help you:

• Understand timelines and scheduling
• Navigate HOA or city permit rules
• Prepare your home for installation day
• Stay updated on progress and possible weather delays
• Know what to expect after the work is done

If your local roofing contractor is vague, hard to reach, or doesn’t walk you through these steps, you’re already behind.

So… What Should You Look for in a Roofing Contractor?

Glad you asked. Here’s a lightning-round list:

• ✔️ Licensed by the California CSLB
• ✔️ Carries both liability and workers’ comp insurance
• ✔️ Has a local business presence
• ✔️ Offers a written contract and warranty
• ✔️ Can provide 3–5 recent references
• ✔️ Doesn’t pressure you to sign “today only” deals
• ✔️ Knows the Simi Valley climate, styles, and permit needs

And remember—if a roofer can’t explain what they’re doing, why they’re doing it, or how much it costs… they probably shouldn’t be doing it.

Roofing Done Right Starts With the Right Contractor

Don’t let myths (or shady contractors) mess with your home. At Infinity Roofers, we believe homeowners deserve more than just a patched-up roof—they deserve clarity, safety, and confidence every step of the way.

We’re a licensed, insured roofing contractor in Simi Valley with a reputation for honest estimates, dependable crews, and roofs that stand the test of time. Whether you’re patching a leak, planning a full replacement, or just want answers, we’re here for you.

Schedule your free consultation today, and let us show you what roofing service should really look like.

FAQ: What Most Homeowners Don’t Think to Ask

Can you ask a roofing contractor for proof of their supplier relationships?

Yes, and you should! Established roofers often have long-standing relationships with trusted material suppliers. This not only means they’re likely getting better pricing (which can save you money), but it also ensures material availability and access to premium products. If your contractor struggles to name a supplier or only offers “off-brand” shingles, that’s worth a closer look.

Is it okay to ask for a project manager or point of contact?

Absolutely. Large or small, every roofing project should have a dedicated point person who keeps you informed. This person handles updates, answers questions, and helps manage your expectations. It’s perfectly reasonable to ask up front, “Who will be my main contact throughout the project?”

Up Next: Before Your Roofer Arrives…

Read This First:

What Your Simi Valley Roofing Contractor Wants You to Know Before the Project Starts

We break down all the must-know details to help you prep your home, your family, and your schedule for a successful roofing project.